Amazon Super URLs: They Might be Killing Your Reviews!
There’s a strategy that a lot of people are talking about. It sounds wonderful, and it makes a LOT of sense…but guess what…it’s not good!
Maybe you’ve heard about it?
It’s a link that people think you should use.
But in truth…
It’s quietly killing your books and I believe is quickly becoming one of the reasons why so many decent and legitimate reviews are disappearing.
What’s worse is some people are actually using it without even knowing it.
It’s called the Amazon Super URL.
In this article, you’ll learn:
- What an Amazon Super URL is
- How to find out if you are using them – even if you don’t know it
- Why you SHOULD NOT use them
- One special tactic you SHOULD use
What Is An Amazon Super URL?
An Amazon Super URL is a link that was created by going to Amazon, searching for your book using a keyword, clicking on your book, and then copying the link at the top.
That may sound innocent and probably something you already do when you are quickly looking for a link to send someone when they ask, right?
But here is where it gets bad and spammy, and why Amazon probably dislikes these links:
Many authors use them to cheat the system.
You see, the Amazon A9 search engine wants to list the products that bring them the most money for that search query. So, according to Amazon, if a higher percentage of people type in a specific keyword, and purchase your book over others, then your book will rank at the top since it proves to Amazon that YOUR book makes the most sales for that keyword.
Because of this ranking factor in Amazon, many authors have started sending Amazon Super URLs to their fans, thinking that these URLs trick Amazon into thinking that the person didn’t click the link…but instead went to Amazon on their own volition, typed in the keyword, found your book, and bought it.
They believe this because, as you can see, the Keyword term is in the link and that was the link that was constructed when THEY did the search:
Why Amazon Super URLs DO NOT Work
But, let’s break down that Amazon link above and discuss the parts that are important in debunking the Super URL theory:
QID: The QID is the number of seconds since January 1, 1970. Yup…that’s right, there is a time stamp inside of the above link. Each time you create an Amazon link using keyword searches, Amazon marks and tracks it.
Book Rankings Number: This shows where the book ranks for that keyword search at the time of the search. In this case, when I did a keyword search for “Make Extra Money,” Nick Loper’s excellent book showed up as the 22nd book in the results. Because a book’s ranking changes all the time, this set of numbers creates what mathematicians would call a check-sum. It validates whether or not the link is true based on the rank at the particular time it was created and that someone hasn’t manipulated the link.
- Amazon tracks when searches are made – so you’re not fooling anyone.
- Amazon knows if you messed with the link – some people actually recommend you remove the QID or book rankings numbers…haha…oy.
As you can see, Amazon won’t be fooled, and the rest of the link structure ensures your attempt to manipulate (if that is what you were intentionally doing) your rankings with this trick won’t work.
If you don’t believe me, then here’s a modern day example. In the news story, notice that Amazon tracked the bad reviews from one link that was posted in Reddit….and boy did they act!
High percentage of certain type of review from a link? Yup
Chance that link is producing biased reviews? Yup
…I rest my case.
But It Gets Worse…
Amazon’s terms and conditions do not state anywhere specifically that creating links like this is prohibited. However, they do state MULTIPLE times that any “intent” on manipulating their metrics will be dealt with.
So, keep that in mind as you read the following:
NOTE: This is where I start to connect the dots seeing that lots of people have commented losing legit reviews and a high percentage of those reviews being linked to these type of links.
As we authors know, Amazon has been on a witch-hunt to remove biased reviews. Currently, they use an automatic system that scrubs their database of books looking for violations – the rules at this point are convoluted and are difficult to fully understand.
However, what we do know is that Amazon’s criteria for review removal isn’t consistent. I believe this is because their automatic system calculates the potential of biased review based on certain factors – remember, automatic means automated, which means non-human.
So, using certain factors, Amazon decides the probability that a review is biased and should be removed.
Keep that in mind as we discuss how Amazon Super URL’s play into this.
Seeing that you created a link, used a keyword in order to potentially game their algo system, and a high percentage of those who use that link ultimately leave a review, Amazon’s automated system probably sees the connection and combined with other factors, initiates the auto-removal of the review.
Again, this is just another factor that raises Amazon’s review removal response. That’s why not all reviews are removed, and why there is inconsistency across the board.
Again, the above is my belief based on the following criteria:
- Amazon’s review removals are inconsistent
- Working with other authors, I’ve seen a high number of reviews from Super URLs removed
- It is against Amazon’s policy of intent
What Link You Should Use
The best and safest link to send to your raving fans is what I call the base URL. This is the Amazon link up to the 10 digit ASIN number. See below:
Amazon Associate Is Safe
Amazon associate is a program in Amazon where you can create a link, and if someone clicks on it, you earn a percentage of any sale on Amazon within 24 hours.
So, wouldn’t a link you create through this program also be flagged and marked for the reasons discussed above?
Great point. But there are four parts to Amazon Associate that keep us safe and are therefore okay to use – and why I continue to use them myself:
- There are no Keyword Tagging, time tags, or checksums inside of an Amazon Associate link – therefore, there is no “intent” to game the system nor does it affect their algo rankings.
- Amazon actually encourages the use of Amazon Associate links to point to your own book – therefore, they basically say these links are a-okay.
- As someone who loves using Amazon Associate links to point to his books, I’ve never seen any adverse effects of using them.
- When you sign up for an Amazon Associate account, you sign terms and user agreements, making yourself an official Amazon affiliate. You’ve – supposedly – read and understand their rules.
If you are creating links this way in hopes to game the system, then stop. I’ve proven that they don’t work, and you are only endangering your potential reviews.
If you are using these links by mistake, then I recommend using the base URL instead to minimize the risk that such links are endangering your reviews.
Either way, they don’t work and there is GREAT potential that these links are frowned upon by Amazon and their automatic review removal system.
So link wisely my friends!